| Date | Time | Opponent | Score | |
| Thu, 9/3/2009 | 7:00 PM | vs Fairview Christian | 3 - 1 | Win |
| Tue, 9/8/2009 | 5:00 PM | vs Christian School of York | 3 - 0 | Win |
| Tue, 9/15/2009 | 4:00 PM | vs Mount Calvary | 3 - 2 | Win |
| Fri, 9/18/2009 | 4:00 PM | at Bible Baptist | 0 - 3 | Loss |
| Mon, 9/21/2009 | 4:00 PM | at Dayspring Christian Academy | 1 - 3 | Loss |
| Thu, 9/24/2009 | 5:00 PM | at York | 3 - 2 | Win |
| Fri, 9/25/2009 | 4:00 PM | at Lititz Christian | 1 - 3 | Loss |
| Mon, 9/28/2009 | 5:00 PM | vs Conestoga | 2 - 3 | Loss |
| Fri, 10/2/2009 | 4:00 PM | vs Bible Baptist | 1 - 3 | Loss |
| Fri, 10/9/2009 | 4:00 PM | at Mount Calvary | 3 - 0 | Win |
| Fri, 10/16/2009 | 4:00 PM | vs Lititz Christian | 1 - 3 | Loss |
| Tue, 10/20/2009 | 5:00 PM | vs Dayspring Christian Academy | 1 - 3 | Loss |
| Fri, 10/23/2009 | 5:00 PM | at Conestoga | 3 - 1 | Win |