| Date | Time | Opponent | Score | |
| Fri, 12/9/2011 | 7:30 PM | vs Christian School of York | 37 - 27 | Win |
| Sat, 12/10/2011 | 7:00 PM | at Conestoga Christian | 27 - 49 | Loss |
| Tue, 12/13/2011 | 6:00 PM | at High Point | 33 - 46 | Loss |
| Tue, 12/27/2011 | 5:00 PM | vs New Covenant | 32 - 23 | Win |
| Tue, 1/3/2012 | 6:00 PM | at Veritas Academy | 30 - 43 | Loss |
| Fri, 1/6/2012 | 6:00 PM | at Lancaster Christian | 30 - 40 | Loss |
| Tue, 1/10/2012 | 5:30 PM | vs Conestoga Christian | 36 - 48 | Loss |
| Thu, 1/12/2012 | 5:30 PM | at New Covenant | 44 - 36 | Win |
| Tue, 1/17/2012 | 6:00 PM | at Lititz Christian | 33 - 31 | Win |
| Fri, 1/20/2012 | 5:00 PM | at Linden Hall | 33 - 17 | Win |
| Tue, 1/24/2012 | 6:00 PM | vs Veritas Academy | 28 - 34 | Loss |
| Fri, 1/27/2012 | 6:00 PM | at Conestoga Christian | 38 - 37 | Win |
| Tue, 1/31/2012 | 6:00 PM | vs Lancaster Christian | 33 - 32 | Win |
| Sat, 2/4/2012 | 6:00 PM | at High Point | 24 - 32 | Loss |
| Tue, 2/7/2012 | 6:00 PM | vs Lititz Christian | 24 - 33 | Loss |
| Wed, 2/22/2012 | 7:00 PM | at Greenwood | 20 - 59 | Loss |