| Date | Time | Opponent | Score | |
| Fri, 12/11/2009 | 7:00 PM | at Christian School of York | 2 - 56 | Loss |
| Sat, 12/12/2009 | 7:00 PM | at Johnstown Christian | 7 - 22 | Loss |
| Fri, 12/18/2009 | 6:00 PM | at Salem Christian | 30 - 43 | Loss |
| Tue, 12/22/2009 | 6:00 PM | vs Bible Baptist | 11 - 56 | Loss |
| Mon, 1/4/2010 | 7:00 PM | at Valley Forge Christian | 15 - 31 | Loss |
| Tue, 1/5/2010 | 6:00 PM | vs Hershey Christian | 13 - 20 | Loss |
| Fri, 1/8/2010 | 6:00 PM | at Lititz Christian | 10 - 44 | Loss |
| Mon, 1/11/2010 | 7:00 PM | at Mount Calvary | 15 - 40 | Loss |
| Thu, 1/14/2010 | 6:00 PM | vs Living Word | 20 - 29 | Loss |
| Tue, 1/19/2010 | 6:00 PM | vs Lancaster Country Day | 11 - 55 | Loss |
| Thu, 1/21/2010 | 5:30 PM | at New Beginnings | 17 - 44 | Loss |
| Tue, 1/26/2010 | 6:00 PM | at Conestoga Christian | 22 - 56 | Loss |
| Thu, 1/28/2010 | 6:00 PM | at Valley Forge Christian | 18 - 32 | Loss |
| Fri, 1/29/2010 | 6:00 PM | vs York | 15 - 38 | Loss |
| Mon, 2/1/2010 | 6:00 PM | vs Salem Christian | 34 - 37 | Loss |
| Fri, 2/12/2010 | 3:30 PM | at Lancaster Christian | 28 - 40 | Loss |
| Sat, 2/13/2010 | 2:00 PM | vs Harrisburg Christian | 22 - 48 | Loss |