| Date | Time | Opponent | Score |
| Tue, 9/8/2009 | 4:00 PM | vs Christian School of York | L 1-6 |
| Tue, 9/15/2009 | 4:00 PM | vs Mount Calvary | L 0-1 |
| Fri, 9/18/2009 | 4:00 PM | at Bible Baptist | L 5-1 |
| Mon, 9/28/2009 | 4:00 PM | vs Conestoga | T 1-1 |
| Mon, 10/5/2009 | 4:00 PM | at Harrisburg Christian | L 3-1 |
| Tue, 10/6/2009 | 4:00 PM | vs Lancaster Christian | L 0-4 |
| Tue, 10/13/2009 | 5:00 PM | at Hershey Christian | L 2-0 |